These 4 PS Smooth Side 2 Master Room/1 Bedroom/Buffet/Lounge/Observations were delivered to Pennsylvania Railroad in May '38.  They were used on the "Broadway Limited" and "Liberty Limited."  All were retired in '60 and '61 with Skyline View and Metropolitan View going to Mack Lowery in Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, and Washington View going to Mexico, and Federal View to Jones Properties.